NEW HAMPSHIRE CAMP DIRECTORS ASSOCIATION

Economic Impact Study

The Economic Impact of the Camp Industry on
the State of New Hampshire

 

Prepared for NHCDA by Tuck Student Consulting Services

 

May, 2008

 

 

This document was prepared using survey data collected and compiled by members
of the Tuck School of Business’ Class of 2009 as a part of
the Tuck Student Consulting Services program.

 


 

TABLE OF CONTENTS                                                                 Page

 

  

Appendices                                                                                         Page

 

Appendix A: Survey Instrument Used in Gathering Data               11                                                                      

 

Appendix B: Data Methodologies                                                       13

 

Appendix C: Data for Day vs. Residential vs. Both Camps            14                                                                            

Appendix D: Bank Balance Contribution on US Economy            16                                                                          

 

 

 

  1.  Summary of Economic Impact

 

New Hampshire has a long and rich tradition in camping, extending back over 100 years, and continues to be the location of some of the finest camps and facilities in America. The beautiful mountains, lakes, forests and fields are ideally suited for every camping activity imaginable.  In their 100-year history, New Hampshire camps have provided an outlet for youth from throughout the state and the country to get closer to nature and learn leadership in the great outdoors. Additionally, New Hampshire camps have continued to provide jobs and economic stimulus to the New Hampshire economy.

With 177 camps in New Hampshire running the gamut from residential, day and combination camps, these facilities provide services to nearly 150,000 youths each year. 

Table 1. New Hampshire Camps by Type and Participants

 

Day

Residential

Combination

Total

Number of Camps

64

100

13

177

Number of Program Participants Served

51,411

67,293

29,921

148,626

% of Participants from New Hampshire

88%

23%

20%

45%

 

To estimate the camping industry’s impact on the New Hampshire economy, NHCDA surveyed industry members’ operational and capital spending in the state of New Hampshire.  Additionally, NHCDA looked at the number of program participants and visitors that are drawn to New Hampshire on an annual basis, and estimated the impact of their spending on the New Hampshire economy.  

 

Analysis of survey results indicates that the total economic impact on New Hampshire of the camp industry’s activities is approximately $159 million per year, including the direct and indirect spending effects.

 

The social and economic impact of NH camps is summarized in the following:

 

 

While this direct economic contribution accounts for nearly $82 million annually, the multiplier effects of the payroll and downstream spending of the New Hampshire vendors are estimated to provide an additional $0.93 in economic impact for each dollar spent by the New Hampshire camps.  This multiplier brings the total economic impact of New Hampshire camps to $159 million.

      ll.  Direct Impact of Camps in New Hampshire

 

Demographic Data

 

New Hampshire’s camp industry contributes to both the social and economic vitality of its communities.  With 177 camps throughout New Hampshire providing day, residential and combination programs, the camp industry introduces campers to the beauty and serenity of New Hampshire’s great outdoors.  These camps serve as stewards in their community, maintaining nearly 24,000 acres of New Hampshire wilderness and more than 373,000 feet or 70 miles of waterfront throughout the state. As stewards of the land, New Hampshire camps take great care and responsibility to maintain New Hampshire’s beautiful landscape with care for the benefit of future generations.

 

The 177 camps in New Hampshire represent small businesses that provide year-round economic contributions to their communities. Not only do they employ more than 2,900 New Hampshire residents, but these camps also bring more than 7,000 additional seasonal employees to the state each year. With more than 150,000 campers in New Hampshire camps each year, this industry is a foundation for many rural communities throughout the state.

 

Below is an analysis of the demographic components of the New Hampshire camp industry.

 

Table 2.  New Hampshire Camps by Types and Participants

 

 

Operational Spending

 

The direct operational spending of camps in New Hampshire contributes approximate $70 million to the New Hampshire economy each year.  While the actual spending by camps is higher, analysis was restricted to the New Hampshire economic impact. Salaries to New Hampshire residents represent nearly 45% of the total operational spending, benefiting approximately 3,000 residents of the state with meaningful employment. A table calculating the estimated operational impact of New Hampshire camps is below.

 

Table 3.  New Hampshire Camp Industry’s Operational Spending

 

 

Tourism Spending

 

The camp industry brings approximately 67,000 visitors to the state of New Hampshire from out-of-state parents and prospective campers. These visits often include numerous outlets for localized spending, such as hotel rooms, restaurants, gas stations and activities.  According to the Institute for New Hampshire Studies, the average tourist to New Hampshire in the summer spends $91.50 per person per night. While the Institute for New Hampshire Studies shows an average trip length in the summer of 4.2 days, this study uses a more conservative 2.5 days per trip to mimic the camp industry’s visitor-weekend duration. The total economic impact of these parental visits can be seen below.

 

Table 4.  New Hampshire Camp Industry’s Tourism Impact

 

Total Direct Impact

 

The direct impact of the camp industry on the economy of New Hampshire is a combination of operational and tourism spending. This direct impact measures the expenditures that can be related directly to the camps and does not include the downstream effects of the dollars spent by the camps and their patrons, which are captured below in the multiplier effect. A summary of the total direct impact is below. 

 

Table 5.   Direct Economic Impact of Camps on New Hampshire

Category

Amount

Operational Spending

$69,794,492

Tourism Spending

$12,466,735

Total Direct Spending

$ 82,261,187

 

 

 

      lll.  Total Impact of Camps in New Hampshire

The camp industry in New Hampshire contributes $82 million in direct effects to the economy. Each of these dollars represents a purchase of goods, services, and labor throughout New Hampshire. While the direct spending can easily be tracked, there are also indirect downstream effects that can also be attributed to the New Hampshire camp industry. Each vendor who is a recipient of direct camp spending in turn makes purchases from the New Hampshire economy, and this spending trickles down the supply chain.

 

These direct and indirect effects provide income for individuals and households throughout New Hampshire, who then make purchases in the state with that income. Camp employees spend their earnings at local stores, restaurants, etc. The workers at these locations then make their own purchases, pay taxes, pay their rent, and so on, which continues to add to the New Hampshire economy. These effects are referred to as the induced impact of camps. 

 

These supply stream effects create a combined direct, indirect and induced impact of the camp industry of New Hampshire of nearly $159 million.

 

Multiplier Effect

It is impossible to measure actual total impact of camps’ spending in New Hampshire; every dollar spent cannot be precisely traced as it flows through the economy. While businesses and individuals may know generally where their income comes from, neither tracks where each individual dollar they spend originates.

 

The Bureau of Economic Analysis collects data on purchases across industries, and creates an output that provides a breakdown of the inner workings of the economy, showing relationships among more than 400 industries and commodities.1  Various groups then take this information and make it more useful for state and regional analysis.  One such example is the Minnesota IMPLAN Group, which uses this data to estimate local economic effect of an additional dollar spent.2

 

The 1.93 multiplier used in this study is taken from the Maine Youth Camps Economic Impact Report, 2005, which used IMPLAN data to estimate a multiplier of the direct impact of the camping industry. This multiplier is in line with the New Hampshire state and outdoor/recreation multipliers that the state derived from the IMPLAN model and with multipliers from the federal government’s Regional Input-Output Modeling System (RIMS II).

 

1  See http://www.bea.gov/industry/ for more information

2  See http://implan.com/ for more information


 

Total Impact of Camps in New Hampshire

 

Using the multiplier we can calculate the induced and indirect effect on New Hampshire’s economy to be approximately $77 million for a total impact of nearly $159 million.

 

Table 6.  Total Economic Impact of Camps on New Hampshire

 

Category

Spending ($ ’000)

NH Camp Expenditures

$      69,794,452

Tourism Impact

$     12,466,735

Total Direct Impact

$     82,261,187

          Multiplier

1.93

Induced and Indirect Impact

$     76,502,904

Total Impact of Camps in New Hampshire

$   158,764,090

 

 

 

 

 

 Appendix A: Survey Instrument Used in Gathering Data

 

The survey was distributed to 177 camps throughout New Hampshire. With 41 completed survey responses, this economic impact survey is based on 24.8% of the total industry. While the total economic spending by New Hampshire camps includes payments to vendors outside of the state, the survey focused on in-state payments to vendors and employees.

 

 Below is the survey instrument used to collect data from the surveyed camps.

 

 

The list of camps was provided by Phil Steele at the NHCDA. Surveys were sent to most camps via email, and the remaining by regular mail. Camp directors and each member camp were called prior to sending the survey to increase response rate.


 

Appendix B: Data Methodology

 

Before analyzing our sample of 41 day, residential, or day and residential camps, each observation was multiplied by the following weights to match the population total as follows:

 

 

Day

Residential

Both

Total NH

Sample # of camps

4

33

4

41

Population # of camps

64

100

13

177

Percent of Population #

6.3%

33.0%

30.8%

23.2%

Sample weight

16

3.0

3.3

4.3

 

 

Next the raw total estimates were adjusted to account for the fact that the survey responses contained a disproportionate number of large camps.  This was done by dividing each estimated total by the following capacity scale factors so that the total weekly capacity matched the published industry capacity total:

 

 

Day

Residential

Both

Total NH

Sample Capacity

675

6037.0

708.0

7420.0

Population Capacity

5755

15237.0

2218.0

23210.0

Percent of Capacity

11.7%

39.6%

31.9%

32.0%

Capacity scale applied to Raw Estimate Total

1.9

1.2

1.0

 


 

Appendix C: Data for Day vs. Residential vs. Both Camps

 

Once adjustments were made for the sample size and capacity (see Appendix B), the following table was generated on the estimated economic contribution of day, residential, or day and residential combination camps. 

 

 

Day

Residential

Both

Total NH

Acres

877

20,178

3,202

24,256

Waterfront footage

50,985

289,665

33,242

373,891

Weeks of operation (summer)

350

639

138

1,126

Weeks of operation (year-round)

1,142

1,333

548

3,023

Number of program participants

51,411

67,293

29,921

148,626

Number of program participants (from NH)

45,273

15,512

5,927

66,712

Number of families

32,288

29,434

11,049

72,771

Number of families (from NH)

29,994

6,017

1,053

37,064

Number of camp parent visits

-

53,618

13,471

67,089

Number of camp parent visits (from NH)

-

11,249

1,341

12,590

Number of prospective camper visits

-

4,768

479

5,247

Number of prospective camper visits (from NH)

-

404

254

658

Seasonal Employees

1,492

6,696

1,378

9,566

Seasonal Employees (from NH)

1,134

1,113

282

2,529

Full-time Employees

77

434

116

627

Full-time Employees (from NH)

43

265

97

405

Balances in NH Banks

3,921,926

19,317,048

5,961,658

29,200,632

Assessed value of NH land

30,224,407

214,540,549

18,639,972

263,404,928

Insured value of plant and equipment in NH

107,021,208

235,467,298

46,330,511

388,819,017

Payroll (including benefits)

8,235,891

16,868,525

6,572,830

31,677,246

State and Local Taxes

1,409,839

2,052,492

303,324

3,765,655

Loan Repayments

-

2,460,297

639,085

3,099,382

Food

142,545

3,604,463

2,311,983

6,058,991

Construction and Capital Equipment

786,602

6,683,670

711,138

8,181,410

All other expenditures to NH-based vendors

365,165

11,449,340

5,197,263

17,011,768

Total Expenditures

10,940,042

43,118,787

15,735,623

69,794,452

Out of state visitor contribution

-

9,691,979

2,774,756

12,466,735

Total direct Expenditures

10,940,042

52,810,766

18,510,379

82,261,187

Induced and Indirect Impact  (=0.93* Direct)

10,174,239

49,114,013

17,214,652

76,502,904

Total NH Impact

21,114,281

101,924,779

35,725,031

158,764,090

 


 

Appendix D: Bank Balance Contribution on US Economy

 

The survey also collected data on the cash balance of any NH bank accounts.  From these data the cash savings of camps is currently estimated at $29 million. Since 1991 the Federal Open Market Committee has set the bank reserve requirement at 10%. This means that for every dollar taken in as a deposit, the bank can loan $0.90. Eventually this $0.90 is deposited and again the bank holds 10% in reserve and loans out $0.81. This process repeats so that each dollar saved potentially boosts the economy by $10. This is known as the money multiplier effect.

 

From our data we estimate that the camp cash savings balance has a $290 million impact on the US economy.  Unfortunately, as banks are increasingly national entities, even though the cash is held in a New Hampshire branch, it is impossible to estimate what fraction of the $290 million total impact indirectly contributed to the New Hampshire economy.

 

Category

Spending ($ ’000)

NH Camp Cash Balances in NH Banks

$      29,200,632

Reserve Requirement

10%

Money Multiplier effect = 1/(Reserve Requirement)

10

Total Impact on US Economy

$   290,200,632